My account:  Log in  |  Create account
GSMchoice: 305 brands  |  15 353 phones  |  104 704 opinions  |  4 439 users on-line
Search phone



An independent expert will assess the Nokia ad

On the occasion of the invasion of new Finnish smartphones, the world has learned a bit about the way Nokia is filming commercials. As the matter turned out to be morally ambiguous, there was appointed a specialist on ethics.

Is it allowed to criticize an ad? After all, we all know that ads lie, mislead, using social tricks urging customers to buy certain goods. We all know that, right? - However, the problem still occurred. There were doubts. We wrote about them recently illustrating the article with Nokia’s commertial video.

Doubts would not arise if not The Verge service, which in a hour after publishing the video noticed a van with the film crew with a decent camera and lights reflecting in the window of the passing trailer. Doubts probably would not have appeared if the advertising producer did his work a bit more professionally.

Neither the industry nor the users do not forgive such mishaps. – The manufacturer’s explanation that literally anywhere it hasn’t been established that the video was recordered with Lumia 920 and that it wasn’t meant to mislead anyone, doesn’t make any sense here. The commercial makes it clear that this is so. Commentators herald worse sale of Lumia 820 and 920, and the fans of the brand announce a change of colors or express outrage.

Simulation of OIS technology Simulation of OIS technology Simulation of OIS technology
Simulation of OIS technology (video frames)
photo: Nokia

A specialist is to explain whether there was a breach of ethics in Nokia’s commercial or not. How did it happen that there was no information that the video is recorded with a professional equipment and not the smartphone camera and indeed whether such information should be included in the advertising spot. In my humble opinion, anonymous and independent expert would have to be a magician. The first impression can be made only once. I believe that if the Lumia 920 turns out to be an attractive smartphone it will be sold regardless of this what has happened.

There is no reason not to criticize the ad falsely administered in their idyllic vision of reality and presenting the perfect products. It is worth remembering that the criticism of advertising is directed toward the producer, not the product, though also the product, in this case runs the risk of infamy. Statistically advertising is profitable; the majority of consumers can be fooled. Most of us agree to support commercial delusion, provided that the illusion won’t be brutally dispelled, that a whistleblower doesn’t appear. When someone demonstrates an obvious scam, we prefer to punish others for our gullibility.

I do not know if the Nokia’s gaffe says more about the mechanisms operating in case of large corporations, or the inconsistency of human nature. I do know that I will treat Lumia 920 without prejudice. Or at least I’ll try to.

Author's text based on Bloomberg; viewed: 5408 times.

Monika Krasicka-Kulińska

  • One HTC ST - Chinese mid-range device

    One HTC ST - Chinese mid-range device

    HTC One ST with a dual-SIM, which launch was officially announced by the manufacturer in China, is a noteworthy mid-range smartphone. It runs Android 4.0 with HTC Sense 4, and is powered by a 1GHz dual-core processor.

    New colours of Galaxy SIII

    New colours of Galaxy SIII

    Samsung, encouraged by the success Galaxy SIII model, which has already sold more than 10 million units, introduces a new colour versions of this model: amber, ruby, sapphire and titanium.

  • Dual-SIM Galaxy Note?!

    Dual-SIM Galaxy Note?!

    There is no doubt that phablets Note and Note II are the Samsung's success. We can be sure that the Korean company wants to maximize the success by introducing new versions of its hit device. One apparently appeared in China ...

    Nokia prepares Flame

    Nokia prepares Flame

    Although the launches of two new smartphones with Windows Mobile 8 are behind us, the sparrows chirp that Nokia is preparing for its users one more, this time a cheap smartphone, code-named Flame.

  • Dual-SIM, ICS and IP67

    Dual-SIM, ICS and IP67

    Today, another pinch of exoticism - another phone designed for the Chinese market. Yes, you guessed it is, of course, a dual-SIM model. But this time it is waterproof. I introduce Lenovo A660.

    iPhone 5 officially announced

    iPhone 5 officially announced

    Phew! The end of rumours and speculations. The latest generation of iPhone was presented in the Yerba Buena Center in San Francisco. We already know everything! The presentation, in a typical Apple style, was led among others by the CEO of Apple Tim Cook.

  • Apple copied Nokia ... or vice versa?

    Apple copied Nokia ... or vice versa?

    After the release of the iPhone, it's time to smile a little. As we know, Apple is suing whom it can, alleging copying products. After the presentation of new iPods at once there are voices that Apple is also not a prude...

    Lenovo for women

    Lenovo for women

    Who said that women don't need decent smartphones? Lenovo to meet the needs of women presented colour model S720 with durable battery, Android and 1 GHz processor.

  • Better than a human eye: a 5-inch Oppo Find 5

    Better than a human eye: a 5-inch Oppo Find 5

    Close your eyes and imagine a competitor for the Samsung Galaxy S III. It has a 5-inch display with a resolution of 1080p, 4-core processor and a thickness of 6.65 mm. Open your eyes. This is not the Galaxy S IV, but Oppo Find 5.

    New Grand with 4-core Tegra 3

    New Grand with 4-core Tegra 3

    ZTE boasts in the press release that Grand Era is the thinnest smartphone in the world with quad-core Tegra, but only it gives the average thickness of the cover and the thickness at the thinnest point. Is the thickness of the case so important?

Sorry, there are no opinions yet.

Add your opinion!

Last viewed phones
You haven't seen any phones yet